Safe Ship founder and CEO Roger Vance joined Dan Ronan on SiriusXM's On the Move, the transportation show that airs on Road Dog Trucking Channel 142. They walked through the difference between a moving broker and a carrier, why so many moving complaints start with bad expectations, and how fuel prices and mortgage rates are squeezing both carriers and families. Listen in the player, or read the conversation.

Interview Transcript

Automatically transcribed and edited for punctuation and readability. Speaker labels are inferred from the conversation. Proper names and unclear wording may require audio review. Statements are reproduced as spoken and have not been fact-checked.

Part 1

Announcer

From Washington, D.C., and from every highway, truck stop, and loading dock in America, this is On the Move, America's transportation conversation. Here's your host, Dan Ronan.

Dan Ronan

5:04 Eastern Time. This Road Dog trucking weather update brought to you by Amazon Trucking. Amazon Trucking, our sponsor here on SiriusXM channel 142. News time is 5:04.

Joining us on the Newsmaker Line from Boca Raton, Florida, Roger Vance. He's the CEO of Safe Ship Moving Services. It's a moving brokerage company specializing in interstate household goods, and he has a background in business from Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia. He has built a logistics intermediary, a company that connects businesses with a nationwide network of licensed, insured moving companies.

It's good to have you with us, Roger. Thank you for joining us.

Roger Vance

Thank you for having me.

Dan Ronan

Roger, what is the difference, to those who don't know the difference, between a moving broker and the carrier?

Roger Vance

So a carrier is the company that owns the physical assets, such as, you know, the trucks. They have the laborers that actually come and physically pick up the goods. Whereas a broker is someone that a customer hires in order to vet the moving companies, vet the laborers, and also find a service that matches their budget. That's the big difference between the two.

Dan Ronan

But there are moving companies that do direct-to-consumer moves as well. We had on a CEO a couple of weeks ago from, I think it was College Hunks. They're direct to consumers. So there are different types of relationships between those that are hiring for moving services and those that are providing it.

Roger Vance

There are, and there are also a lot of moving companies—carriers—that also broker moves as well. And so they'll still serve a dual role. And I also own a moving company as well in Los Angeles called Boulevard Moving, and they have 33 units, box trucks and trailers that they use. But two separate entities altogether. So we keep the actual brokering to just one company and then the actual moving to another.

Dan Ronan

Moving is a particularly difficult thing to do. I've done it numerous times in my life, and like anyone who's done it more than once, I don't like doing it. It's not anything that's high on my list of things to do. But there seems to be a disproportionate number of consumer complaints about moving companies.

Why do you think that is? Is it because there's a lack of transparency or financial accountability? Where does the process break down, and where do you think it can be improved?

Roger Vance

That's a loaded question, and I could talk about that for hours.

Dan Ronan

Well, how about 20 minutes?

Roger Vance

So I would start off by saying that—and I say this to my company during our morning meetings every day—almost all issues that happen in moving comes from the lack of setting proper expectations. And if the customer's expectations aren't set properly, then they're going to end up upset.

Explaining to the customer, like, these are movers. These are guys that are going to come in, they're going to work hard. They probably have been in a truck for six hours already to get to you. If you think they're going to show up at eight o'clock on the dot, sharp, as soon as the second hand strikes eight, then you're probably going to be left disappointed, because there are tons of variables that come into play, whether it be weather or traffic that could cause them to be late.

But by setting the expectations, almost like when Comcast comes: “Oh, we'll be there between one and five,” right? Then the customer's expectations are set, and then they're not upset. So it's the same situation, but different expectations.

I think, secondly, another reason that there's so many consumer complaints is because the barrier to entry in this particular industry is extremely low. The Department of Transportation requires only a $75,000 surety bond, which can be purchased for around $1,200, and then you can become a moving broker.

And that may be a good thing, it could be a bad thing, but it allows a lot of bad actors to operate, get a bad reputation, close shop, open a new one, and start doing the same thing again under a new name.

Dan Ronan

And so do we have to lower our expectations, Roger, or do we have to change them?

Roger Vance

So I have been working heavily with lawmakers, both in Florida and in Washington, D.C., to raise the bar that's required in order to enter this industry in the first place, both through a higher financial barrier of entry, a larger bond, as well as having references, and also having a nationwide database to where, if you've started a moving company and you did a terrible job and gave a bunch of customers a nightmare experience, then we should be readily able to see that's happened and not allow you to try again, you know?

So a few different things that are in the works to try to stop what the industry calls “chameleon carriers,” where they just do a terrible job, then they shut down shop—same trucks, same warehouse, same workers, just new name online—and then they're right back into business.

Dan Ronan

To that end, we have a serious problem in the overall trucking industry. It appears as though FMCSA, the regulators and the like, are at least taking some steps to try and tighten things up. Are they going about it the right way? Is it too wide of a net? Is the net too narrow? Your thoughts?

Roger Vance

I think it's unfortunate that the way the statutes have been written, the FMCSA has little to no authority to actually enforce things. And they can do audits and they can do inspections, but ultimately their fining ability has been taken away completely. And so typically they'll have to refer to the Department of Transportation to apply any fines, and ultimately to the Department of Justice to have anything criminally done.

And so that's why a lot of these things skate under the rug, and these guys keep operating, because while it is bad, it doesn't rise to the level to where the Department of Transportation, the Department of Justice, take an interest in it.

Dan Ronan

And the Department of Justice is working on a lot of important items as well, criminal, civil issues. Is a bad move, as you said, does it rise to the level of getting the DOJ involved?

Roger Vance

Right, and I would say for the vast majority of cases, no. But there are circumstances where we've got, you know, for instance, about six years ago, there was a broker in South Florida, and they were taking deposits and then dispatching the moves with absolutely no vetting of the carriers whatsoever. And they were sometimes not even taking a deposit and not even dispatching a job whatsoever.

And the FMCSA ultimately ended up uncovering these warehouses that were just jam-packed full of people's stuff. Nobody knew who the stuff belonged to, and it was just haphazardly thrown in a warehouse. You know, when it rises to that level, I think the DOJ may take interest in that.

Dan Ronan

Roger, have you ever had, in your moving career, have you ever had a move that's just gone perfectly, where you've said to yourself, “There's nothing I wouldn't have changed in that”? Have you ever had a perfect move?

Roger Vance

Yeah, I've had numerous moves. The vast majority of our moves, only great things to say. We do about six thousand—

Dan Ronan

Roger, hang on that thought for one second. We're having a little bit of a signal problem. At 1-888-876-2336, 1-888-876-2336, Roger Vance joins us on the Newsmaker Line. The website is safeshipmoving.com. He's in Boca Raton, Florida. He's the CEO of Safe Ship Moving Services, a moving broker specializing in interstate household goods transportation.

We'll continue our conversation with our guest, who'll be with us till the bottom of the hour. It's SiriusXM channel 142.

Part 2

Announcer

Welcome back to On the Move, America's transportation conversation where transportation's leaders, innovators, and frontline voices come together. Here is Dan Ronan.

Dan Ronan

It is 5:18. Roger Vance, the CEO of Safe Ship Moving Services, he joins us from Boca Raton, Florida. The website is safeshipmoving.com, talking about accountability, moving, and broker transparency and accountability as we talk about the moving industry as well. Roger, what information do you recommend that the brokers put in writing when they get a contract and when the contract gets put together between the mover and the person who will be using the moving services? What do you need in the contract?

Roger Vance

So basically, we will get the bill of lading details from every carrier that we work with. And then when we're speaking with the customers and we're formulating an estimate that would ultimately be acceptable to them, it's within the guidelines of what whatever particular carrier we're going to assign them to has on their bill of lading. So typically, that involves the tariffs, the fuel surcharges, whatever, additional bulky fees, long carry fees that will be applicable to that move, but also, as importantly, what the customer's budget is. There's no sense in applying the tariffs of a company that's going to be outside of that customer's budget.

Dan Ronan

In this day and age, Roger, with diesel prices as volatile as they are, can you really, with a move that is 35, 40, 60 days out, can you really commit to a price that everybody is pleased with concerning fuel? How hard is that to do?

Roger Vance

It is very difficult on the carriers, and as a result, about a month ago, we company-wide increased the fuel surcharge by 20% on all of our moves in order to ensure that the carriers' margins aren't being squeezed to the point where it just doesn't make sense for them to accept the jobs anymore.

Dan Ronan

So you had to make a change in the business model?

Roger Vance

Yeah, you know, there's been a ton of inflation since COVID, and it will slowly and surely work its way down to the consumers, and, you know, the companies, the moving companies have tried their best to, you know, take on that additional cost ourselves, but at a certain point, that cost has to be passed on to the customers or else it doesn't make sense anymore. And so it was honestly a long time coming.

Dan Ronan

Can you make a profit now with the policy that's in place, and are you in a situation where you might have to change it again at some point down the road?

Roger Vance

I think it's always a possibility of changing in the future and increasing. As we know, prices rarely go down, they only go up, but, you know, we have seen since 2020, our margins drop to the single digits, so.

Dan Ronan

Also, we have got home mortgage rates in the low 7% to the highest they've been in a year. That can't be helping the moving industry right now very much as well.

Roger Vance

Oh, no, it's killing it. This is, there's more home sellers than there are home buyers by the widest margin in I think the last 20 years. So, not very many people move in as opposed to two years ago.

Dan Ronan

Yeah, if you've got a mortgage rate that's 4.5%, 5% from the good old days of four or five years ago, six years ago, do you really want to make a change if you can hold on because you're going to be paying at a minimum $300, $400, $500 more in interest rates and that doesn't do anything to the principal, that just moves the interest rate around.

Roger Vance

Yeah, and it just raises the prices because all these mortgages are like interest heavy at the beginning of the mortgage. So, you know, when most people are purchasing a home, the biggest number that they're paying attention to is what is that monthly payment and the higher the interest rate, the higher that payment's going to be.

Dan Ronan

So let's talk about that and walk through this, if you will, for me. We're looking at a move, so-and-so decides they've been relocated or they're going to be moving to another part of the country, family, work, whatever the case may be, they start talking to the moving company maybe 90 days out, 60 days out in that window, but things will change in that time period, fuel prices, whatever the case is. So what can be changed during the move or right up till the time of the move that's not in the original quote?

Roger Vance

So with us, we have a binding estimate fee. So when we tender an estimate to a customer, that estimate is binding. And so our job is trying to predict what are we going to be able to service this move profitably for whenever the move has to be serviced. And so, you know, if diesel prices go down, then all those moves get much more profitable than they previously were. And the inverse is also true. So once a customer signs, that price is the price. The only thing that can change is what the customer intends to move. And we have a price per cube that we charge. So if you choose to move more cubes than you originally intended, of course the price is going to go up, but the price per cube will stay the same. The fuel surcharge percentage of the total move will stay the same.

Dan Ronan

So you're trying to, like a good quarterback, you're trying to throw the ball to where the receiver is going, not to where the receiver was.

Roger Vance

Correct.

Dan Ronan

It's tough to do. I mean, you got to be really good at your job.

Roger Vance

We do. And as a result of being in business for five or six years and having all of that data aggregated, we are able to refer to historical data in order to help us make those determinations.

Dan Ronan

How did you yourself get into the moving business? You've got a business education from Liberty—good school—down in southwestern Virginia. How did you find yourself in the moving business, Roger?

Roger Vance

Well, originally I was just a salesman and I sold insurance. I sold vacations. And there were moving brokerages around, which was a place that a lot of salesmen worked. And I saw that it was a very soft industry. It did not have a ton of innovation. A lot of technology hadn't been implemented in it yet. And I saw that there was a lot of room for growth there. And so I also happened to have a friend who had started a moving brokerage and I asked him if he could help me start one and show me the ropes and he did. And that's ultimately where this entire business snowballed from. This year we're anticipating 76,000 families will get moved with us.

Dan Ronan

Like the taxi cab industry 20 years ago when the services came in that are now ubiquitous that we're all using as well. Is this an industry that is ripe for disruption? That it is ready to be changed, its business model is to be changed like the ride sharing business was with taxi cabs?

Roger Vance

I personally believe so and in numerous ways. For one, with just automated trip planning software, as well as with software that can anticipate costs and build budgets and balances for you. But also, you know, like in the near future, it's a very real thing that we could have, you know, driverless semi trucks. We could have robots that are doing manual labor for us and that could drastically change the industry.

Dan Ronan

But who's going to pack the boxes? Who's going to be the person packing the house up and getting it ready?

Roger Vance

So a lot of our customers are PBO, which means packed by owner. But you know, ultimately, I think, you know, when we're looking 20, 30, 50 years down the road, I think that's something that could be automated through technology.

Dan Ronan

No kidding. So have some sort of a robot or have some sort of a piece of equipment, move the furniture and get it out to the truck and secure it, possibly?

Roger Vance

Right.

Dan Ronan

What would that look like? I'm curious to what's the vision that you see?

Roger Vance

Well, I mean, if you look at some of the releases of like the Boston Dynamics robots, I mean, they can, they can perform fine motor movements, they can play violins, and they can like tie shoestrings. And so I don't think it's outside of the realm of possibility that if you know, the world stays stable, and growth continues, and AI continues to grow at the exponential rate that it's growing, that these robots wouldn't be able to do something like, you know, pack a box with dishware, make sure that they're wrapped in bubble wrap, so they're not banging against each other, and then stack it perfectly inside of the truck.

Dan Ronan

Certainly would lower the number of backaches and knees that the movers, the packers feel after you know, being on the job for a couple of years.

Roger Vance

Absolutely. I don't think that the human element will ever be fully replaced. But I think that it'll be utilized in the same way that technology in the past is being utilized. You know, there are still farmers, there's just not as many of them. And they don't have to go out there and do the backbreaking work themselves. They're not hoeing the fields themselves. They have plows and combines that do it for them.

Dan Ronan

Roger Vance joins us on the newsmaker line from Boca Raton, Florida. He is the CEO of the company called Safe Ship Moving Services. He's a moving broker that specializes in interstate household goods transportation. Roger, good to chat with you. The website safeshipmoving.com. Been an interesting discussion. I hope we get the opportunity to do this again.

Roger Vance

Yeah, thank you for having me, Dan.

Dan Ronan

Thank you, Roger. Been a great conversation as well. Coming up next, Tim Snyder, founder and economist at Matador Economics. We're going to discuss fuel inflation and the freight economy. Coming up next, SiriusXM 142.

That is the full conversation from Roger's appearance on On the Move with Dan Ronan. Press play on Part 1 and Part 2 in the player to hear it in his own words. If you are planning an interstate household move and want a licensed broker to match your inventory and budget with a vetted carrier, start with a written estimate from Safe Ship.